My
interest in this subject was sparked after reading an article in TIME magazine (June
2000). They published an article called "MUSIC AND THE BRAIN", which delved into
the possibilities that music may have a profound effect on the development of various
skills in children. Since then I have been absorbing anything I can find on the subject
and use it to promote the importance of music education to not just potential musicians,
but to all children.
Although many people may be aware that music has some kind of an effect on them,
most people assume its a purely spiritual or emotional experience. Music evokes
emotions like sadness, love, resolve, and peacefulness perhaps even violence. But
is it really purely an emotional experience or does it affect the human body physically
and are there scientific after-effects and proof of his?
Many pre-school and kindergarten teachers are well aware that children learn
best through songs and music forms a large part of the teaching process at an early level.
However, as children grow older, they seem to sing less and less as part of their learning
process and as most of us know, music is almost an endangered species in our current
school system. It falls under the umbrella of arts and culture so less time is available
for teaching music lessons.
In spite of the influence that music has on humans, scientists have not spent
much time to understand why or how it affects us so profoundly. Until very recently in
terms of human history and scientific research, we have merely accepted that music affects
us, but that we dont know how, why or even what the after-effects could be.
According to documentation of the American Music Conference, the earliest studies recorded
were by a Dr. Gordan Shaw in 1985.
In February 1997 Dr Shaw and his partner Dr Frances Rauscher of the University
of Wisconsin proved that pre-schoolers who studied piano performed up to 34% better in
spatial and temporal reasoning abilities than pre-schoolers who spent the same amount of
time learning to use computers.
Pre-schoolers who took singing and keyboard lessons scored 80% higher on
object-assembly tests than students at the same pre-school who did not have music lessons.
(Rauscher and Shaw Oct. 1996)
In a study of medical school applicants, 66% of music majors who applied were
admitted, the highest percentage of any group. Only 44% of biochemistry majors were
admitted. (Study by Lewis Thomas, 1994)
Rhythm students learn fractions better: After learning eight, quarter, half and
whole note concepts, second graders scored 100% higher than their peers who were taught
fractions using traditional methods.
Scientists are not yet exactly sure how or why this occurs just that
there is a definite link between brain development, mathematical skills and cognitive
skills in children. What is also clear is that the ability to experience and react to
music is deeply embedded in the biology of the nervous system. While music tends to be
processed mostly in the right hemisphere of the brain, there is no single set of cells
devoted to this task. Different networks of neurons are activated, depending on whether a
person is listening to music or playing an instrument, and whether or not the music
involves lyrics.
A larger area in the auditory cortex, which is the section of the brain that
brings music and speech into conscious experience, is responsive to piano tones in adult
musicians compared with non-musicians. In addition certain brain structures are also
bigger in musicians. (see picture) The primary motor cortex and the cerebellum, which are
involved in movement and coordination, are larger in adult musicians than in people who
dont play an instrument.
The area that connects the two sides of the brain the corpus callosum -
is also larger. German scientists found that the brain area used to analyse musical pitch
is an average of 25% larger in adult musicians. The younger the musical training begins -
the larger the area.
Musically trained adults perform better on word memory tests than other adults.
Children who take music lessons may experience advantages with respect to some
cognitive and perception skills. Pre-school children, who had piano lessons for about 6
months, perform better than other pre-school children on puzzle-solving tests.
Researchers then tried to improve this music effect by adding other training
components.
One study found that second-grade kids who took piano lessons and played special
computer math games, scored higher on math tests than children who played the math games,
but had English language instruction instead of piano lessons. Scientists are now testing
whether the addition of another set of lessons, which incorporates the PC games into the
schools standard math programme, will boost the young pianists math results
even more.
Preliminary findings indicate that second-graders who received this version
perform as well as fourth-graders in fractions, ratios, symmetry, graphs and other algebra
problems.
So is it just any type of music that has this effect? Perhaps it
doesnt matter, but what has been proven is that certain types of music have a
greater effect than others. Rats exposed to intricate Mozart melodies completed a maze
more rapidly and with fewer errors than other rats exposed to silence or with noise.
On the other hand researchers say that just listening is not enough. Listening
to music (including Mozart) has a smaller effect than learning to play any kind of music
on a musical instrument.
There are still many questions unanswered. One of the teachers asked why most of
the studies seemed to concentrate on piano and keyboard skills - why not the violin or
flute for instance? Perhaps its one of the easiest instruments to teach at a very
young age. I think that different skills are probably more advanced in musicians who play
different instruments. For instance in this age of technology at the relatively old age of
18, I taught myself to type and use a computer. Perhaps being a piano player had something
to do with the fact that I started to type with two fingers and after six months worked my
way up to eight fingers and about 60 words per minute. I still use only eight fingers and
my word count is probably a bit higher now, with the added bonus that I dont have to
look down or think about where the keys are anymore.
After absorbing all of these facts, it is clear that there are still many
unanswered questions regarding music, intelligence and brain development. For instance:
why do we appreciate music and why do some of us favour certain types of music to others,
while other people like completely different types of music?
Did our musical ancestors have an evolutionary edge over other mere mortals? Is
that perhaps why people like Mozart and Beethoven could compose so many great pieces of
music? Perhaps they were an elite few who could play, read, write and understand music in
a world where most other people could not.